Performance management tools: our top 9 choices for HR
.png)
What people ops professionals and team members expect from performance management processes is changing. While performance management used to be a flexible, top-down process encompassing little more than a set number of performance reviews per year, it’s changing to meet the evolving needs of the world of work. Specifically, people-centered organizations are moving toward collaborative, continuous performance management cycles comprising a dynamic ecosystem of assessments, feedback, and check-ins — as well as learning and development initiatives.
While all of this is great, setting up modern, multi-faceted performance management systems can be challenging. That’s why we’ve compiled this comprehensive breakdown of the top performance management tools on the market.
We’ll review each tool’s pros and cons and discuss why it is considered one of the best performance management tools. This comprehensive breakdown will empower you to make informed decisions.
👌 Leapsome brings all elements of performance management together
Explore how our suite of tools can enrich your approach to performance management and improve the employee experience.
👉 Take a 5-minute product tour
*The information below is based on our research between May and July 2024. All user feedback referenced in the text has been sourced from independent software review platforms (like G2 and Capterra) in June 2024.
Leapsome offers modular pricing, starting at US$8 per user per month.
13
4.8
15Five’s pricing ranges between US$4–16 per user per month, billed annually.
1
4.7
ClearCompany’s pricing information isn’t readily available.
3
4.4
Engagedly’s pricing starts at US$5,000, billed annually.
7
4.6
Mitratech Trakstar’s pricing isn’t readily available.
1
4.4
Motivosity’s pricing isn’t readily available, but the minimum annual spend is US$3,000.
13 — some in beta
4.8
US$5–10 p.p./mo (billed annually); engagement features add US$1–3 p.p./mo.
1
4.8
US$5–7 p.p./mo (billed annually); engagement features add US$2 p.p/mo.
1
4.2
Workhuman Conversations’ pricing isn’t readily available.
34
4.8
.svg)
Top features of a performance management tool
Different organizations have different ideas of what makes for an ideal employee performance management tool — but you should always keep the following key features in mind when searching for a performance management tool.
Best-practice templates
While creating templates for evaluations and meeting agendas from scratch is great, many busy people teams don’t have the time. That’s why choosing a performance management system with best-practice templates you can tweak and customize is ideal.
Automation
Automation can save hours of employee time. However, research shows that 43% of professionals aren’t leveraging this technology. When choosing a performance management tool, pick one that’ll take work off your plate rather than piling it on; a top-tier solution should trigger reviews and kick off cycles automatically.
People analytics
Repeat after us: Data is our friend! It’s not easy to make performance decisions, but data can make your thought process a lot more straightforward. Prioritize platforms that allow you to use data in your performance management processes to monitor trends, identify problems, spot high potential, facilitate succession planning, decide on promotions, and target training investments.
💡 A holistic platform for holistic performance
Forget about a one-dimensional, top-down approach to performance management! With Leapsome’s suite of tools, you can tackle it from all angles.
.svg)
1. Leapsome
.webp)
Leapsome is an award-winning people enablement platform that empowers organizations of all sizes to take a truly holistic approach to performance management. Our eight modules work together, so people teams can establish and maintain a cycle that addresses performance from all angles to benefit employees, managers, and the business.
Our modular design also means you can adopt the features that best suit your company and build a custom, continuous performance management system that propels your organization toward its most ambitious goals.
While all of our modules contribute to holistic performance management, Reviews, Instant Feedback, Goals, and Learning are indispensable tools to improve employee performance:
- The Reviews tool allows managers to streamline and automate the administrative work that comes with evaluations while helping them deliver more meaningful, growth-oriented appraisals.
- Instant Feedback eliminates one-off review remarks and prompts all team members to share candid praise and feedback as part of their daily work.
- Our Goals feature enables leaders, managers, and individual contributors to set growth-oriented goals for themselves and understand how their work contributes to their team and company’s bigger-picture objectives.
- Learning allows managers and reports to collaborate on professional development and upskilling and gives employees access to high-quality learning materials.
- Many modules, like Goals and Reviews, have AI-powered capabilities to save you extra time
- Ideal for managing remote, hybrid, and on-site teams
- Powerful visualization and analytics tools
- Free, out-of-the-box Meetings feature that comes with all modules
- Outstanding customer support
- 13 languages supported
- A wide variety of integrations
- SSO and encryption features
- ISO 27001 compliance
- Leapsome is continuously expanding its offering, and is currently developing new HR features
- jhjkhhkjhkjhkj
- hjkjhkjhkjhjk
- khkjhkjhkjhk
- No mobile app yet (but fully mobile responsive)
- Continuous platform improvements may lead to occasional bugs
- The variety of features can result in a slight learning curve at first
- kjlkjhkljkljlk
- kjlkjljl
- khkjhkjh
-
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
2. 15Five
15Five is a performance management tool and employee engagement software designed to help people teams improve communication, productivity, and team member development within their organizations. The platform supports managers in maximizing employee performance, increasing engagement, and enhancing their leadership skills to nurture high-performing teams and drive businesses toward their objectives.
- Helps synthesize data to see what’s been accomplished
- Gives a great overview of team status
- Granular insights when compared with competitors
- Straightforward and easy to use
- Great customer support
- list item
- Some users feel the platform is on the expensive side
- Some users report issues with the 1:1 feature
- Not as comprehensive a solution as some other options on the market
- A lack of help articles
- list item
3. ClearCompany
The ClearCompany performance management tool is part of the broader ClearCompany talent management software. The platform makes it easy for organizations to manage their human resources team effectively and streamline onboarding, talent acquisition, and performance tasks. It also allows people managers to implement an employee-first approach to performance management, conduct better evaluations, provide better feedback, and simplify the review cycle.
- Helpful resources for users, like webinars
- Intuitive to use and navigate overall
- Easy to customize so it fits with your organization and workflows
- Good reporting and analytics features
- Cost-effective solution
- list item
- Some users say specific features, like new hire onboarding, can be hard to navigate
- Some users feel the performance tool is missing features
- Some bugs and slow loading times reported
- list item
4. Engagedly
Engagedly is a people management solution that simplifies and incorporates employee engagement into its performance-tracking tools. The platform is designed to help HR leaders effectively manage team members, track performance over time, and work more efficiently. Engagedly enables users to set and manage goals, collect 360° feedback, and recognize employee achievements.
- Various tools to support performance, like Overviews, Feedback, Check-Ins, and Goals
- Team members can request and share feedback
- Easy for admins to set up, implement, and manage
- Highly customizable
- Great customer support
- list item
- Not a comprehensive HR management solution
- Some users report that the app is complex to use
- Some users want more automation capabilities
- list item
5. Mitratech Trakstar
Mitratech Trakstar is a comprehensive talent management solution that uses features like 360° feedback and goal tracking to maximize team members’ performance. People professionals can use the performance management tool to set and track employee goals, collect different forms of feedback, run engagement surveys, and manage reviews.
- Helps streamline evaluation processes
- Highly customizable
- Great customer support during implementation
- Useful cascading goals feature to push corporate and team goals
- Easy to build different kinds of reviews
- list item
- Some users say the platform can be overwhelming to use at the outset
- Some users feel the survey tool is lackluster
- Can be clunky to use and hard to make bulk edits within the platform
- list item
6. Motivosity
Motivosity is a people-first engagement software solution built to boost engagement, forge connections between managers and reports, and enable people leaders to foster a meaningful company culture. What makes Motivosity unique is its ability to recognize and reward team members and create an enjoyable work environment. While it’s not a traditional HR performance management tool, the platform aims to boost performance by focusing on understanding employee sentiment, sharing recognition and rewards, and improving people’s job satisfaction.
- User-friendly, visually appealing interface
- Empowers employees to recognize their colleagues’ contributions
- Possible to give out points that employees can redeem for a gift at the customizable company store
- Real-time insights into recognition trends, engagement levels, and overall morale
- Cost-effective
- list item
- Not a standalone performance tracking tool — needs to be used with another solution
- Some users say it’s difficult to access transaction history
- Some users feel recognition categories could be more creative
- list item
7. PerformYard
PerformYard is a people management platform that can enhance the way your organization approaches employee reviews, goals, and feedback. PerformYard’s business performance management tools are designed to make people management easier, with features for employee appraisals, 360° reviews, quarterly check-ins, project-based reviews, and 1:1s. The platform is also customizable, so you can set it up to suit your organizational needs and preferences.
- Easy to use and implement
- Possible to share organizational goals in many ways throughout the platform
- Simple to identify internal areas for improvement and make data-driven decisions
- Great customer support
- list item
- Some users report the surveys lack customization features
- Some users have concerns that team members won’t use the platform to its full potential
- Reporting features could be improved
- list item
8. Small Improvements
Small Improvements is a continuous performance management tool designed to enable people leaders to help team members grow. Managers can use the platform to share feedback and praise with reports, conduct 1:1 check-ins, organize performance evaluations, run pulse surveys, and set and monitor goals over time.
- Keeps both individual and team improvement top of mind
- Encourages employees to share feedback
- Simple and consistent platform
- Easy to set up performance review cycles for an entire organization
- Wide range of integrations
- list item
- Some users report issues assigning more than one manager to employees
- Some users say team members don’t use the platform for communication as much as they could
- Need for more advanced 1:1 functionalities
- Not enough capabilities for larger organizations
- list item
9. Workhuman Conversations
Workhuman Conversations is a performance management software tool within the Workhumans toolsuite. It unites agile performance development with structured evaluations and feedback to create organizational cultures based on collaboration, growth, and learning.
- Empowers coworkers, managers, and executives to send out quick notes of appreciation
- Possible to give team members points they can use for rewards
- User-friendly interface
- Easy to adopt and roll out company-wide
- Recognition forms are intuitive
- list item
- Some users have experienced issues with reports and filters
- Some users want more variety in terms of rewards and gift cards, especially in countries other than the United States
- Some problems reported with points redemption and the general cost of rewards
- list item
Why customers love us
.svg)
“We've been using Leapsome for over a year, and we love it”
Susie P.
HR manager
AI software (10-100 employees)
“I love how easy Leapsome is to set up and explore as a manager and user”
Sarah S.
Chief operational officer
B2B agency (10-100 emp.)
“Leapsome has provided more ways to keep our employees engaged”
Katy S.
Exec. Administrator & Comms. Manager
Research Services (500-1000 emp.)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
🤝 The best companies
invest in people enablement
Get started with performance reviews, goals & OKRs, engagement surveys, promotion
and compensation management, and more.
.svg){kind=icon}
.svg){kind=icon}
Frequently Asked Questions
Common Pricing questions
